ERPZ Stop Mugging. Start Learning.

Lessons to learn from Norway

Paradise on Earth?

First published in The Guardian on Wednesday, then republished in The Straits Times, Timothy Garton Ash writes about Norway vis-a-vis the European Union, and some of the lessons that can be learnt from Norway and about Norway.

The writer refers to Norway as "close to a paradise on Earth" because of high living standards and social equality. This, he says, allows many people to use Norway as an example for many things. British MPs from the Eurosceptic Conservative party claim that Norway's being out of the EU and its resultant prosperity meant that Britain could leave the EU and probably do as well as Norway could. Researchers also cite Norway as an example of how greater equality could have spillover benefits in terms of education and crime amongst other social indicators. And for those "hydrocarbonists" who support the "drill, baby, drill" faction, Norway is the epitome of how oil drilling can create prosperity and equality, since Norway's economy (and hence social democracy model) is sustained by significant exports of oil and gas drilled in its waters. And there are some who allude Norway's success to its historical and cultural links to the Vikings and their traditions and characteristics.

But the writer would like to remind readers that it is easy to draw "too-simple lessons from the experiences of other countries, or of projecting on to them lessons you want to draw for your own". In short, only highlighting what serves your own purpose and neglecting the rest. One may also fall into a trap, the frequently-commited "fallacy of confusing correlation with cause". The lessons that should be learnt need to be the right ones as well: emulating the success stories of another country in your own, in a totally different context, can produce wildly different results.

And, well, even supposed-Paradise Norway is not immune to the "shockwaves of world politics", as the country struggles (like many other European nations) to integrate its growing Muslim populace and its exports have to be imported by its European neighbours for the country to earn any money at all.

So what can Singapore learn from Norway? Maybe tips on the social democracy model that Norway champions, given that Singapore tends to be averse to some of the ideas of social democracy such as pensions because of disincentives to work. Or perhaps how the country manages to create such an egalitarian society, important given that Singapore is becoming a more unequal society as the country continues to grow and develop.